Boys smile less in yearbook photos after age 11

It's that time of year when yearbooks are making the rounds. After two psychology researchers recently pored more than 18,000 student yearbook photographs, they made an interesting observation -- they found a gender difference in smiling among the classmates.

Between age 10 and 11, or by the time kids reached sixth grade, boys started smiling less than girls in their yearbook portraits, the new research found.

In the study, which was published online in the journal Sex Roles, researchers looked at snapshots of kids from kindergarten through twelfth grade taken between 1996 and 2008 at 17 schools in Michigan.

They focused on the faces in 34 different yearbooks -- zeroing in on the mouth -- to determine if there were any sex differences in smiling across the age groups. Each grin was rated on a 3-point scale with 0 given for no smile, 1 for a partial smile, and 2 for a full smile.

Boys and girls probably received the same "smile" or "say cheese" instructions from the photographer. But there was a noticeable drop off in grinning among the boys by sixth grade, while the girls kept on beaming for the camera.

Asked why boys may have slacked off on smiling, study author Dr. Mihaela Friedlmeier suggests that during their late tween and early teen years, boys and girls get plenty of information about gender-related expectations from parents, peers and the media.

They learn "how to assert themselves as distinctly female (emotionally expressive and friendly) or distinctly male (dominant, aggressive, and nonsmiling)" says Friedlmeier, an assistant professor of psychology at Grand Valley State University in Allendale, Mich.

Researchers also compared the smiling patterns in African American schoolchildren to European American kids. And they considered whether the ethnic diversity of the student body at each school mattered.

"We were surprised to find that African American boys displayed significantly less smile compared to European American boys," says Friedlmeier.

"It's particularly interesting that African American boys from schools with a predominantly African American student population showed less smile compared to those from ethnically mixed schools and those with a majority of European American students," she says. This was true even though there were no major socioeconomic differences in the students at the schools.

Friedlmeier thinks that African American teenage boys may have a different image of masculinity (as appearing "tough") compared to European American boys. And she says it's also possible that historical context might be influencing African American males. She suspects they may be avoiding the "Uncle Tom" image of the smiling Black man, popular in the 1940s and 1950s. Although the young boys clearly weren't alive then, this idea may be internalized and passed down from their parents or grandparents, as well as their peers and the media.

In this Michigan-based study, African American girls smiled a little less than their European American peers. But there may be fewer differences in female smiles because both groups are influenced by similar cultural standards of beauty, explains Friedlmeier.

Friedlmeier hesitates to extrapolate her findings in these Midwest schools to the rest of the country. But if you happen to thumb through your (or your kid's) yearbook, along with noticing the horrible hairtstyles and goofy quotes, see if the smiles vary not only by gender but also by ethnicity.

More from The Body Odd:

 

Want more weird health news? Find The Body Odd on Facebook.

Discuss this post

"We were surprised to find that African American boys displayed significantly less smile compared to European American boys," says Friedlmeier.

-I'm not. Looking at numerous yearbooks from various high schools this can easily be known. The high schools is the less developed area, which have the tendency to have more blacks than whites, the white kids still smile more often. That does skew the data because of the 1:1 ratio, but it still fits the quote nonetheless. Doesn't take a genius to know that. If I had to guess, they want to convey the image of being "hard/bada**" or "cool" so to speak.

  • 1 vote
Reply#1 - Fri Jun 8, 2012 7:34 PM EDT

It's simple: smiling is not manly and women don't find it sexually attractive. Around puberty, boys figure this out ...

"Women find men less attractive when they smile compared to when they take on swaggering or brooding poses, a Canadian study has found."

    Reply#2 - Wed Jun 13, 2012 10:12 AM EDT

    Well that's easy. That's the age they start hating school.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#3 - Wed Jun 13, 2012 4:55 PM EDT

    I actually find a man much hotter if they smile

    • 1 vote
    Reply#4 - Sat Jun 16, 2012 1:13 PM EDT

    This is likely vastly underestimating the factor that by age 11, the teaching methods in Western schools are vastly favouring the way females learn and moving away from the way that males learn. It's perfectly valid to assume a factor may be that boys are finding school more difficult than girls, giving them less reason to smile overall. Heaven forbid anyone complain about the schools favouring girls more than the guys, though. Society expects the males to shoulder whatever hurdles it throws at them without them complaining, while females have people and groups just standing around doing nothing but waiting to help them out.

    • 1 vote
    Reply#5 - Fri Jul 27, 2012 5:38 AM EDT
    You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
    As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.