Distraction reduces pain, study finds

By Joseph Brownstein
MyHealthNewsDaily

When you distract yourself from pain, you actually hurt less, a new study suggests.

Study participants who were subjected to slight pain on their forearms reported less discomfort when they were asked to perform a distracting mental test as the pain was delivered.

Moreover, when participants were given a placebo "pain relief" cream, and distracted at the same time, their pain was even more reduced.

"Both placebo and distraction are effective mechanisms for reducing pain. You can combine them and you don't lose anything," said study researcher Jason Buhle, who conducted the research as part of his doctoral dissertation from Columbia University.

The work sheds light on how the placebo effect may work, Buhle said. Previously, it had been thought that the placebo effect was the result of some — perhaps unconscious — mental effort, but the new results suggest that it relies on a separate mechanism from distraction.

The study was published Jan. 18 in the journal Psychological Science.

Distraction has been found to reduce pain in the past, Buhle said, but the new study showed that those benefits could come in addition to those of a placebo.

The study involved 33 participants. Researchers attached a heating device to their forearms, which delivered some pain.

As a distraction, the participants took what is called a "3-back" test, where they were given a series of letters, and had to say whether a letter was the same as the letter that had been listed three earlier.

In one experiment, participants were also given a cream to put on their arms, and told it was a pain reliever. In another, they were given the same cream, but from a different container, and were told it was simply for the workings of the pain-administering device.

What the researchers found was that the placebo cream and the distracting test both had lessened the participants' pain, but distraction made for a much more effective pain reliever.

"It's clear that [distraction] is very powerful, and it was not uncommon for someone with a distraction condition to say, 'Did you really turn it on?'" Buhle said. "Sometimes they won't even feel the pain… It is striking to see."

By contrast, he said, "Nobody says that after the placebo."

Moreover, the use of a placebo did not appear to change how well participants performed on the 3-back test, which would have indicated some thought being devoted to the placebo itself.

Calling the findings "intriguing," Dr. Ian Cook, director of the UCLA Depression Research & Clinic Program, said the study helps point to a new path for non-drug treatments for pain.

It would be interesting to see the effect of distraction on other conditions where the placebo effect has shown an impact, such as anxiety, Cook said.

In the past, said Cook, distraction has proven to be useful, particularly with children, as a means of reducing pain. Mostly, he said, it has been used in the form of humor, influenced by a 1976 article by Norman Cousins about the healing power of a positive attitude, published in the New England Journal of Medicine.

But distraction goes beyond humor.

"It's not clear whether it has to be something that's humorous, or whether it can be anything else that engages attention and distracts form the painful experience," said Cook.

The use of placebos in medicine has been controversial, in part because it relies on deceiving patients to be effective. Cook said it's clear it is used in some cases.

"Many physicians do, evidently…they'll prescribe an antibiotic for a viral illness, even though that's not likely to have any biological benefit at all," he said.

Cook, who specializes in depression, said he would not prescribe it for his patients.

"It doesn't seem to be of great benefit there," he said. "Once the person learns they've been taking a placebo, once they learn they've been deceived, the benefits tend to dissipate very rapidly."

More from MyHealthNewsDaily

More from The Body Odd:

Want more weird health news? Find The Body Odd on Facebook.

Discuss this post

It's unethical for doctors to prescribe antibiotics for viral illnesses that are unlikely to progress to a bacterial infection. However, I do think that doctors should write out a "prescription" for rest, fluids, and perhaps simple vitamins so the patient can feel that they are really being treated.

    Reply#1 - Tue Feb 7, 2012 7:08 PM EST

    This reminds me of a technique Abraham A. Low discovered/developed 75 years ago. It’s a bit different, he called it ‘objectivity’. Rose VanSickle, author of Peace of Body Peace of Mind, describes it this way: “Doing something objective cuts into runaway thoughts” (fearful thoughts about discomfort, pain, anxiety, etc.). “The purpose is to shift from thinking subjectively about what is going on inside (the feelings and sensations), to thinking objectively about outside of you.”

    Simply put, 'objectivity' is a form of focused concentration. Think of a material object in terms you can verify or measure. You’re reading this article through an online source – so what kind of device are you using? How tall/high is the screen? How wide? Input – keyboard or touch screen? How many keys on the device. Don’t just guess – count them all.

    “Objectivity is not just a means of distraction. The technique will not work if you merely change your thinking to something pleasant—because there is emotion involved in recalling memories.”

    This is just one example of the cognitive-behavioral methods taught in the Recovery International program, part of Abraham Low Self-Help Systems.

    So, you ask: Does this technique really work? You bet it does!! And I am living, breathing proof it does! I was nearly housebound at one time with agoraphobia and depression. Today? There is nothing I ‘can’t’ do.

      Reply#2 - Tue Feb 7, 2012 9:59 PM EST

      Wow, placebo cream and distraction relieve slight pain. Forgive me if I'm not impressed. I want to see them address chronic, debilitating pain, the kind that keeps you from being distracted, before I applaud their research. What they have achieved is confirming what we already know. Think of what we did as children, "oh, your foot hurts?", slug in the arm, "your foot doesn't hurt any more, does it?"

        Reply#3 - Wed Feb 8, 2012 1:51 PM EST

        2 comments:

        I used to be afraid of shots. A nurse taught me, maybe 40 years ago, that if I got a slight slap first, where the shot was to go, I would not feel the pain of the shot because the body cannot feel 2 sensations at the same time. May have also been a way of distraction as well.

        2: As someone with chronic intractable pain I have noticed that distraction works well- at times: When I do something that is pain provoking, I can sometimes become involved enough that I stop noticing the pain until my body and the pain force me to stop. HOWEVER the moment I stop the pain catches up to me and is worse then had I stopped when it first started to escalate. Other people with chronic intractable pain say they have the same experience.

        Carol Jay Levy
        author A PAINED LIFE, a chronic pain journey
        Women In Pain Awareness Group
        #!/groups/111961795481256/
        The Pained Life, 30 years, and counting.

          Reply#4 - Fri Feb 10, 2012 8:56 PM EST
          You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
          As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.