Upside of a stroke: It curbed her urge to smoke

By Randy Dotinga

The 58-year-old woman had tried just about everything to quit cigarettes, but she kept on puffing away. Then she had a stroke. Suddenly, her urge to smoke disappeared.

This recent case out of Cleveland of a stroke actually helping someone's health -- if only amid a blizzard of nasty effects -- suggests that our addictive urges aren't only a matter of conscious choice.

"Clearly, some strokes give us an insight into the biological basis of our behavior," said Dr. Cathy Sila, a neurologist at University Hospitals Neurological Institute, where the patient was treated. "There's sometimes more to smoking than just 'I choose to do this.' It's telling us something that we've got to figure out to help people quit smoking."

The woman's medical saga began when her family noticed she was acting strangely and sought help. Doctors diagnosed a stroke. She underwent a procedure to reduce a blockage in a neck artery and later went home. 

A month after her stroke, the woman said she didn't care about smoking anymore and wasn't even tempted by being around other smokers. She also turned apathetic in general, a factor that could explain her lack of interest in cigs. 

Her stroke may not go down in the annals of medical research. But other strokes have taught scientists about the workings of the brain for a century, said Dr. Brett Kissela, a neurologist at the University of Cincinnati. "By seeing what functions are lost from many, many strokes, we can learn about what each part of the brain does. This is similar to taking out one piece of a car at a time and then testing to see what doesn't work."

So what happened to this patient? The stroke may have damaged the frontal lobe, the place that holds "your ability to plan in advance and multi-task," Sila said. Or it could have disrupted the pleasure circuit in the brain, eliminating the woman's ability to get a kick out of smoking.

Whatever the case, things could change: Within months of a stroke, many patients recover the skills that they've lost. Patients tend to settle into a permanent state -- with or without stroke-related problems -- after about a year, Sila said.

In some rare cases like this one, stroke-related changes can be for the better. Sila recalls the case of an older patient who underwent a drastic personalty change after his stroke. "He was described by his family as an SOB: really mean, angry and bossy, not a very loving and nurturing kind of man. When he had a stroke, he totally chilled. He required help, assistance and supervision, but they liked him a lot better."

Call it that most unusual of medical disorders: a stroke of luck.

Want more weird health news? Find The Body Odd on Facebook.

Discuss this post

This is nothing more than saying a lobotomy can change your personality. Just look at what it did for Jack Nicholson in One Flew Over The CooCoo's Nest.

    Reply#1 - Tue May 17, 2011 10:46 AM EDT

    A woman I went to high school with had a stroke when she was about 27. (She taught aerobics and gymnastics classes every day for a living, btw), and she forgot she smoked. Soneone asked her if she wanted a cigarrette after she got out of the hospital and she said she didn't smoke. They had to show her pictures of her smoking before she would believe it. She never picked up the habit again.

      Reply#2 - Tue May 17, 2011 11:33 AM EDT

      Im glad it helped her quit smoking but what else did she lose. You always lose somthing with a stroke usally more then you think you did.

        Reply#3 - Tue May 17, 2011 3:17 PM EDT

         My friend's Mom also suddenly lost the urge to smoke after having a stroke.

          Reply#4 - Tue May 17, 2011 6:42 PM EDT

          She also turned apathetic in general, a factor that could explain her lack of interest in cigs.

          I wouldn't call that a change for the better!

            Reply#5 - Tue May 17, 2011 6:56 PM EDT

            I had a stroke when I was 30. It was probably about as catastrophic as they get physically, without killing me. Fortunately my memories and most of my cognitive facilities stayed intact, but physically, I "forgot" how to breathe for a short while, and I had to learn to rewalk and retalk, and had a lot of rehab and eventually weight lifting to do. I still notice a few things...breathing and talking are a little funky...my vocal range has changed.

            Cognitively, it did change things. There are some typical things--ability to control emotions for example, or mental blind spots--but it also changed my disposition. I was pretty severely depressed before, and that changed completely after. I don't know if that is because I had to fight so hard to rehab, and I had something to actually make me feel worthwhile, or if it is as mundane as a switch being turned off. I don't remember if there is anything else that changed night and day like that. I'd have to ask.

              Reply#6 - Tue May 17, 2011 9:44 PM EDT

              OK my fellow smokers, they found our cure...let's have a stroke.

                Reply#7 - Tue May 17, 2011 11:27 PM EDT

                About four years ago I got very sick, my doctor said that if I didn't have pneumonia I was on the verge of it. I tried to smoke at the beginning of the illness but I couldn't inhale, it was hard to breathe, never mind smoke. After about five days I felt better but never had the urge to smoke again. I had been a life-long pack-a-day smoker and this happened when I was 54 years old. I can't explain it but the addiction was simply gone.

                  Reply#8 - Wed May 18, 2011 6:52 AM EDT

                  @Moters: She also was pretty stiff on her left side, and she became very promiscuous. She had lots of guy friends after the stroke!

                    Reply#9 - Wed May 18, 2011 10:25 AM EDT
                    You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                    As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.