Body snatchers: Delusion turns loved ones into impostors

Patients with Capgras delusion believe their friends or family members have been replaced with identical-looking impostors -- like a scene straight out of the 1950s sci-fi film "Invasion of the Body Snatchers."

One January day in 2007, a terrifying idea seized a 45-year-old wife and mother in Omaha, Neb.: Her husband and teenage sons were not, in fact, her husband and teenage sons. Strangers who happened to be identical to her family members had taken over her home, and to fend them off, she armed herself with a fireplace poker, called her neighbors -- and 911.

It sounds like something out of the 1956 sci-fi film "Invasion of the Body Snatchers," but the Nebraska mom actually was suffering from something called Capgras delusion, a rare psychiatric disorder in which a patient believes her friends or family members are not who they say they are -- and that the real people have been replaced by identical-looking impostors.

Normally, we recognize faces thanks to a part of the brain called the fusiform gyrus, which is located in the temporal lobe. It processes the faces we see, and sends that information on to another part of the brain, the amygdala, which processes emotions. But in patients with Capgras, there's a disconnect between that visual center and the emotional center, explains Dr. Mariam Garuba, a New York psychiatrist who treated the Nebraska woman when she was admitted to an Omaha, Neb., emergency room three years ago. (Garuba wrote about the unusual case, referring to the patient only as "Ms. A," in a clinical psychiatry journal last year.)

In other words: Ms. A knew that these people standing in front of her looked, talked and acted like her husband and her children, but they didn't make her feel the way she usually did when she saw them.

It's worth noting that if Capgras patients talk to a loved one on the phone, they will recognize the voice. But if that loved one enters the room, the patient will accuse his friend or family member of being an impostor; that's because hearing and sight take different pathways to reach the brain's emotional center. (Extra credit: Watch neurologist V.S. Ramachandra deliver a fascinating speech on Capgras and other brain disorders at a 2007 conference.)

In some cases, that disconnect that is thought to cause Capgras is brought on by a head injury; in others, it's related to an existing psychiatric or neurological disorder. Ms. A falls in the latter group, as a longtime bipolar disorder patient who'd also been diagnosed with multiple sclerosis. Although she'd taken drugs to treat the bipolar disorder in the past, she was taking none in January 2007; she was also not taking any medication for her MS. Her physicians, including Garuba, believed the Capgras delusion occurred because of a relapse of Ms. A's MS. She was treated with antipsychotics, and after a few days, she gradually stopped believing that her doctors were trying to poison her; after nearly a month in the hospital, she stopped believing that her family members were impostors.

The rare disorder is named for Joseph Capgras, a French psychiatrist who was the first to write about the delusion in 1923, after treating a woman who became convinced that her husband and others she knew were actually body doubles. Similar cases to Ms. A's in recent years include a 24-year-old woman who, after some complications with pneumococcal pneumonia led to epileptic seizures, began to believe that some of the ICU physicians had been replaced by impostors. And in the UK, a 42-year-old woman claimed that while she was in the ICU for pneumonia in 1999, each of her family members except for her mother were replaced by aliens.

Of course, we don't know exactly how these patients voiced their suspicions, but it must have at least carried the spirit of this quote from the 1950s "Body Snatchers" trailer: "Listen to me! Please, listen! If you don't -- if you won't -- if you fail to understand -- then the same incredible terror that's menacing me will strike in you!"

Find The Body Odd on Twitter and on Facebook.

Want more weird health news? Find The Body Odd on Facebook.

Discuss this post

This condition has kept life very interesting for actors, politicians, and other luminaries as well as their bodyguards and/or Protective Services firms they employ for a long, long time.

The number of stalkers who show up at the homes of the famous believing that the person they're after isn't really that person but rather an impostor, or even an extraterrestrial impostor, is mind blowing. And, naturally, from a divine summons or whatever other possible motivation occurred to them, they're convinced that it's up to them to intervene. Another frequent scenario is that the stranger is convinced that they are somehow the legitimate spouse of the celebrity and something has gone awry and they need to somehow 'get back' to that celebrity so things will, somehow, all work out 'like they're supposed to be'. Talk about out of touch with reality!

  • 1 vote
Reply#1 - Tue Oct 26, 2010 8:37 PM EDT

There is also a related syndrome called "Cotard's syndrome," in which the sufferer becomes convinced that he or she is dead, and is just a walking corpse, like a zombie.

  • 1 vote
Reply#2 - Tue Oct 26, 2010 9:32 PM EDT

Yes! More on that one later this week ...

    #2.1 - Wed Oct 27, 2010 1:21 PM EDT
    Reply

    the TiGor, maybe you should be grateful not to suffer any of these illnessess, or worse yet, know someone like yourself who seems to lack compassion....talk about being pompous.

      Reply#3 - Wed Oct 27, 2010 1:43 AM EDT

      Just Plain Me, good job illustrating that it takes all kinds of people to make the world go 'round. I'm not exactly the type who's rolling with laughter at the irony of your comment, but what you've inferred is certainly amusing as it is puzzling. You sure seem to read a lot into a factual comment made by a person you've never met before! Notice I never said anything passing judgement on the people who act on such delusions; I certainly didn't decry them as evil or miscreants. I merely shared the observation that the condition discussed in the article keeps famous people and their security details quite occupied. Take it for what it is.

      The US Secret Service estimates that at any given point, over 600 people in the US are somehow convinced that they are under orders from God to assassinate the President of the United States, that they've been chosen and it's their purpose in life. Most probably never have the opportunity or means to act on it, and I'd imagine most do get over it after awhile, if out of frustration over anything else. If you ever wonder why it is the Secret Service takes the extraordinary measures to safeguard the President that they do, this would be a significant part of it.

        Reply#4 - Wed Oct 27, 2010 11:11 AM EDT
        kkrimmerDeleted
        You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
        As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.